There are two important questions that prospective franchisees must ask themselves when considering becoming part of a franchise system: can I comply with the system and the franchise agreement? Is the system compliant with the law, including the Trade Practices Act and Franchising Code of Conduct (the Code)?
Franchisee compliance
The existence of a system and franchisee compliance with that system are the essence of franchising. All successful franchise networks have a tried and tested franchise model and franchisee compliance is a key factor in that success. Franchisee compliance adds strength to the system and the franchise network.
To determine whether a franchise system is one with which you will be able to comply, it is imperative that you educate yourself. It is critical that you read all of the legal documents carefully, including the franchise agreement and the disclosure document. Don’t leave the reading to your advisors, because something that is standard from their point of view might be something that you cannot live with or abide by.
You should also seek a copy of the franchisor’s operations manuals. The franchise agreement generally only deals with the parties’ general obligations. It is the operations manual that will deal with the system attributes and what is required of you on a daily basis. You should ask for the operations manual, firstly to verify that there is an active, functioning system and secondly to ensure you’re able to abide by it.
Sometimes franchisors are unwilling to provide a copy of their operations manual prior to the franchisee signing the franchise agreement. If so, ask to review it at the franchisor’s offices.
Franchisor compliance
In deciding whether a system is compliant with the Code, one of the first indicators is its disclosure document. Despite the Code’s existence for 12 years there are still many networks whose disclosure documents do not comply with it. Although some non-compliance may be trivial, it does send a message about the attitude of the franchisor.
Areas of non-compliance with the Code include:
- Failure to provide the franchisor’s financial statements for the last two financial years or an auditor’s statement
- Failure to provide financial statements and audit reports for the marketing fund
- Failure to disclose key events such as the number of terminations and sales in the network and details of franchisees who have left
- Failure to disclose material facts, including about litigation affecting the franchisor or its directors
While some business opportunities are licenses or distributorships, you should be wary of a franchisor claiming that the system is not a franchise but rather a licensing or distribution arrangement in an attempt to avoid having to comply with the Code.
If an arrangement satisfies the four pillars of the definition of a franchise agreement within the Code, it will be a franchise agreement irrespective of what the arrangement is called. Put simply, if there is an agreement (written, verbal or implied), a system or marketing plan, a trademark and the payment of fees, the arrangement is very likely to be a franchise.
The ACCC is continuing to crack down on non-compliant systems. Since the Code was enacted some 12 years ago there have been a substantial number of cases where the arrangement in question has been held to be a franchise.
The consequences of non-compliance can be severe for all parties concerned and for franchising as a whole. While non-compliance by the franchisor will primarily be the franchisor’s problem if monetary penalties are imposed and the franchisor is required to put in place a trade practices compliance program it can impact on the whole network and its viability.
As a prospective franchisee you should educate yourself about the Code, the system, the agreements and the operations manual. You should listen to other franchisees, ex-franchisees and to your professional advisors.
This article was written by Raynia Theodore, corporate & franchising team at Mason Sier.